NewsFamily of Chinese tourists killed in Malaysia wall collapse seeks US$378,356 compensation

January 10, 2025

NewsFamily of Chinese tourists killed in Malaysia wall collapse seeks US$378,356 compensation

January 10, 2025

A father and daughter died after an uprooted tree and part of a wall fell on their car in Penang.

Rescuers remove the bodies of the victims from the car wreckage in Penang last September. Photo: Facebook/BombaMalaysiaOfficial
A family from China is demanding 1.7 million ringgit (US$378,356) in damages for the deaths of a father and daughter after an uprooted tree and part of a wall fell on their vehicle in the Pinang Peranakan Mansion car park in Malaysia’s Penang state last September.

Their lawyer Ng Kian Nam said the family has initiated legal action against five parties, namely the museum operator, proprietor, tree owner, local tourist agency and tour guide/driver engaged by the duo during their trip.

“The family has authorised us to also write to the Penang Island City Council (MBPP) to seek an explanation why it only issued a notice of nuisance under the Local Government Act 1976 to the tree owner after the incident but not before that; and whether the said parties had submitted any official complaints to the council of the risk of the tree falling.

“The main cause of action will be based on tort, the Civil Law Act 1956, breach of duty of care, trade custom and statutory duties,” he told a press conference in Bayan Baru on Friday.

The victims were Liu Zhu, 69, and his daughter Liu Xinxin, 36.

They leave behind Xinxin’s mother, husband, sibling and 11-year-old child, Ng added.

“The father was a retiree receiving a retirement allowance of 3,200 yuan (US$436) monthly, while the daughter was an employee with a monthly salary of 12,000 yuan (US$1,636) and they were among the main breadwinners in their family.

“As such [the family] wishes to claim apology and total damages of 1.7 million ringgit against these parties in general and special damages,” the lawyer added.

Ng said he took up the case on a pro bono and public interest basis to increase awareness of the importance of maintaining the safety of public areas in Malaysia and to uphold Penang’s tourism reputation.

It was reported that on September 18, a man and his daughter were killed in the car park of Pinang Peranakan Mansion in Lebuh Gereja, George Town.

A wall with the tree in question growing off it had collapsed onto the car that the tourists were in at the time, killing them on the spot.

https://www.nknp.com.my/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/nknp_logo.jpg
https://www.nknp.com.my/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/icon_malaysianbar.png

© Copyright 2024 Ng Kian Nam & Partners, Advocates & Solicitors.
All rights reserved.

Kuala Lumpur

C-6-8, Block C, Plaza Mon't Kiara, No. 2, Jalan Kiara, Mon't Kiara, 50480 Kuala Lumpur.
+603-2704 7686
+6011-1093 3109
+603-2704 7687
nknp.adm@gmail.com

Follow us:

Negeri Sembilan

195-1, Jalan Haruan 5/6, Pusat Komersil Oakland 2, 70300 Seremban, Negeri Sembilan, Malaysia.
+606-6310 229
+6012-3310 140
+606-6312 170
nknandpartners.adm@gmail.com

Follow us:

Penang

No. 54, Tingkat 1, Jalan Mahsuri Mukim 12, Bandar Bayan Baru, 11950 Bayan Lepas, Pulau Pinang.
+604-638 3109
+6011-5503 3109
nknp.penang@gmail.com

Follow us:

Johor

H-03-16, Block H, Komersial Southkey Mozek, Persiaran Southkey 1, Kota Southkey Mozek, 80150 Johor Bahru, Johor.
+607-338 3379
+6011-5583 3109
nknp.johor@gmail.com

Follow us:

Need Help? Chat with us